Editor's Picks
← All Collections

The Collection · The Best Of

Editor's Picks

The pieces I'd bring home first

A Note from the Editor

The pieces I'd bring home first — the ginger jar, the hydrangea stems, the blue stripe throw, the pink beach cruiser. If you buy nothing else, buy these.

Every issue we ask ourselves the same question: if a reader wrote in tomorrow and said, 'I have one afternoon and a modest budget and I want the room to feel like Nantucket by supper' — what would we send them? These are the answers. Not the trendiest pieces, not the most expensive, not the ones our affiliate partners want us to push. The ones we would put in our own houses first.

There is a blue-and-white ginger jar on the list because a ginger jar solves a mantel or a console or an empty corner in a single gesture. A bouquet of faux mophead stems because they carry the summer through the winter. A blue-stripe quilted throw because a slipcovered sofa without one looks unfinished. A pink beach cruiser with a wicker basket because — well, because a pink beach cruiser with a wicker basket, parked against a gray shingle wall, is a whole feeling.

Also on the list: a Nantucket lightship basket handbag that will outlive us both, a set of Royal Check canisters that make even a Monday kitchen look like it's expecting company, a rattan chandelier that turns any dining room into a summer supper, and a coastal-stripe cotton rug that pulls a whole room together for less than dinner for four in town. Start here, and let everything else follow.

The Collection · 12 curated pieces

Chinoiserie Blue & White Ginger Jar

Home Decor

Chinoiserie Blue & White Ginger Jar

$45·at Amazon

The piece that ties a mantel together — my grandmother kept one on either side of the clock and I've never seen a room that wasn't better for it.

Details
INXUGAO Artificial Blue Hydrangea Bouquets — 10 Faux Mophead Stems

Porch & Garden

INXUGAO Artificial Blue Hydrangea Bouquets — 10 Faux Mophead Stems

$29·at Amazon

Full, realistic blue mophead blooms that look freshly picked — the stems I'd tuck into a pair of white urns flanking the front door for instant Nantucket curb appeal, no watering required.

Details
Levtex Home Martha Blue Stripe Quilted Throw (50x60)

Pillows & Throws

Levtex Home Martha Blue Stripe Quilted Throw (50x60)

$58·at Amazon

The blue stripe is the most Nantucket thing in this whole shop — fold it on the end of the guest bed and watch every visitor want to take it home.

Details
Max4Out Pink Beach Cruiser Bike with Wicker Basket (24")

Bikes

Max4Out Pink Beach Cruiser Bike with Wicker Basket (24")

$199·at Amazon

Pink frame, wicker basket, fat tires for sandy roads — this is the bike I would have killed for as a kid pedaling to 'Sconset for ice cream.

Details
Farnum Vintage Nantucket Lightship Basket Handbag

Baskets

Farnum Vintage Nantucket Lightship Basket Handbag

Vintage·at Etsy

The real thing — a true Farnum Nantucket Lightship basket purse with a scrimshaw-style 'America' yacht plaque on the lid. The island heirloom that every other basket is trying to be.

Details
MacKenzie-Childs Royal Check Enamel Canisters (Set of 3)

Kitchen

MacKenzie-Childs Royal Check Enamel Canisters (Set of 3)

$248·at Amazon

Heirloom black-and-white check that turns the counter into the focal point — these get handed down, not packed away.

Details
Coastal Dog Toile Woven Blanket (Labrador Retriever)

Pillows & Throws

Coastal Dog Toile Woven Blanket (Labrador Retriever)

$76·at Etsy

Blue-and-cream toile with lighthouses and Labs — the whimsical beach-house throw I want draped over every Adirondack chair on the porch.

Details
Lilly Pulitzer Beachside Rattan Tote with Blue Stripe Straps

Bags

Lilly Pulitzer Beachside Rattan Tote with Blue Stripe Straps

$168·at Amazon

Rattan, blue stripes, just deep enough for a beach towel and a paperback — this is the bag of the summer, every summer.

Details
30.7" Large White Rattan 3-Tier Boho Coastal Chandelier

Indoor Furniture

30.7" Large White Rattan 3-Tier Boho Coastal Chandelier

$289·at Amazon

A three-tier hemp-rope drum chandelier in soft white — the kind of fixture that turns a dining room into a 'Sconset cottage in one swap. Layered, breezy, and quietly the focal point of the room.

Details
SAFAVIEH Montauk Handmade Stripe Cotton Rug, Ivory & Light Blue (9' x 12')

Rugs & Mats

SAFAVIEH Montauk Handmade Stripe Cotton Rug, Ivory & Light Blue (9' x 12')

$285·at Amazon

Soft sky-blue cabana stripes on ivory cotton — the flat-weave I'd lay down in a sunny living room or a kid's bedroom on the island. Looks like it's always been there.

Details
Blue Striped Linen Coastal Accent Chairs with Nailhead Trim (Set of 2)

Indoor Furniture

Blue Striped Linen Coastal Accent Chairs with Nailhead Trim (Set of 2)

$899·at Amazon

Navy-and-cream ticking stripe, rolled arms, ball-turned wood legs — the slipcovered club chairs I'd pull up to a round jute rug and a driftwood coffee table for full bay-window 'Sconset energy.

Details
18" Nautical Jute Rope Wreath with Coastal Blue Hydrangea Bow

Porch & Garden

18" Nautical Jute Rope Wreath with Coastal Blue Hydrangea Bow

$78·at Etsy

A chunky braided jute sailor's-knot wreath finished with a hand-tied blue hydrangea ribbon — the front-door piece every Nantucket shingled cottage seems to have.

Details